2.19.2009

perfect (to me) chocolate chip cookies

I've tried countless recipes and methods in search of the best chocolate chip cookie. There's that Neiman Marcus recipe that was circulated on the internet that calls for flour made from blended oatmeal. Tried that one. There is a method that involves dropping the cookie sheet flat on the floor right after taking the cookies out of the oven in effort to help them settle more quickly. Tried that too. I've experimented with butter vs. margarine vs. butter/margarine combos vs. butter/margarine/crisco combos. Here is a list of the tips I use to make 'em the right way.
  • Just use the recipe on the back of your choco chip bag
  • Use butter
  • Multiply the amount of salt by 3 or 4. Trust me. The recipe I use calls for 1/2 teaspoon. The last time I made cookies I put in 2 teaspoons. It still could have used a dash or two more. You don't really taste the salt. It just helps to cut the sweetness. With more salt in the cookie you can better taste the vanilla, the chocolate, and the butter. 
  • Add an extra 3/4 to a full cup of flour. This is something I picked up from making cookies with my pal, Ina. The dough should really clump to the beater and should be tacky to the touch. When you touch it with your finger, it will leave just a little behind.
  • Make them the right size. I use a teaspoon (from my silverware drawer, not a measuring spoon) to scoop the dough. I use my fingers to form the scoop into a ballish shape while it is still on the spoon, then drop it on the cookie sheet. They don't have to be perfect spheres but they should be about the same size.
  • DO NOT OVER COOK THE COOKIES. This is really the most crucial tip. They should be pulled from the oven the moment that 1) the bottom edges just start to golden up 2) the cookies no longer look wet on the top. You are going to want to leave them in longer, but don't do it! They will continue to cook on the sheet after you take them out. My recipe said to cook them 9-11 minutes. Here is what the cookies looked like at 8 1/2 minutes. They are really close. One or two are just a little wet on top and they haven't quite started to brown at the edges. 
  • One minute later they were ready. Here they are just out of the oven. Barely golden at the edges and puffy. 
  • Let the cookies settle on the sheet for 2-3 minutes. The cookies will deflate and will look slightly darker. If you try to take them off too soon, they will fall apart. If you leave them on to long, any chips that are touching the sheet will start to stick. The cookies will be really soft when you take them off. You may be tempted to put them back in the oven. Don't do it! I use a spatula to get under the edge of the cookie then carefully twist it to loosen it from the sheet. Remove the cookies to a cooling rack.
  • Leave them on the rack for at least 5 minutes. They will deflate a bit more. But really, the objective is to prevent storage condensation by getting them cooled off before sealing them up.
  • Store them in something air tight. Saran wrap need not apply. Stored in an air tight container, the cookies will stay soft and chewy for... well. I don't know exactly. They don't last very long around here. But they stay soft and chewy.
  • Finally, share them! A cookie shared is a cookie spared (from my waistline). I divide them up and get them ready for delivery as they come off the cooling rack, thus eliminating any chances of falling victim to my weak will power.

14 comments:

Ina said...

Dang! that just made me really want cookies and we so don't need them today but we don't have much going on which leaves too much time to think about cookies.
I think I do all those things except the salt, I will have to try that, and the butter I know it is better but I am so dang cheep. May I add one more suggestion. I am totaly a milk chocolate person when it comes to candy bars and Dove chocolate but I really believe that in a chocolate chip cookie semi sweet chips are the way to go.

p.s. Do you remember when I made the salt cookies for my english class. They looked so good and tasted sooooooo bad.

Zach 'n' Jack said...

you are a very wicked girl! I am sure you know that by posting this, everyone who reads your blog will be overcome with the power of chocolate chip cookies. OH dear....I feel it now....I better go make some and follow all your tips! i can hardly wait!!!

Cameron/Melissa said...

I agree that I too want cookies. But I need to clean my house and loose weight so I better not! Good idea about sharing though.

Sunshine and Rain said...

Oh, yes! I agree with all of the above! Thank you for sharing your secrets of perfect cookies . . . I am going to try them!

Love
Mom O

Jessica G said...

I want cookies...but mostly I'm laughing over the memory of dropping cookie sheets on the floor! Good times! Thanks for helping me remember that! I do most of that but the extra salt thing is something I will definitly have to try out. And if you want some mean chocolate peppermint cookies...i'm making them tonight! Too bad you can't come taste them!

Stacie said...

Those are great tips! I agree with all of them (except that I have a certain recipe I like over the one on the bag). I haven't tried the salt trick though...perhaps I will next time. Yum...looks great!

Stacie said...

P.S. I have decided that mixing semi-sweet and milk chocolate chips makes the best tasting cookie to me.

Jesse said...

Ladies- Thanks for weighing in on the chip issue. I usually use dark chocolate. I just ran out and made this particular batch with 1 cup milk chocolate, 1 cup peanut butter. Maybe that's why I felt like they could have used more salt. I'll have to try the milk/dark combo when I get a chance!

Darcy said...

Thanks for the tips. I've never tired more salt, but it makes sense. Here's a tip for you: add molasses and almond extract to your recipe. So good!

Susy said...

Great tips Jesse, Thanks!

Ina said...

I succumbed. I have no will power.

Amy said...

I appreciate your in-depth analysis and tips.!! I need all the help I can get in the kitchen.

Camille said...

So should I expect mine in the mail any day now??
YESSSSSSSS!!

They look fantastic. Great post!

Anonymous said...

I also made cookies last night after I saw the post. EVIL!!!!! but oh so good. :)